Update on My Insurance Holdings

Kansas City Life Insurance (OTC:KCLI) is a smallcap life and health insurance company with a long and stable history. In the company's Q1 earnings report their investments were down $38 M due to the market downturn. Consequently the company equity dropped $3 per share but book value is still $81 per share.

	KCLI	EUPIC
Price	$29.4	€ 3.69
Marketcap M	$282.24	€ 101.47 ($ 114.97)
ROE %	2.6	11.8
PE	14.11	6.55
PTBV	0.36	0.78
Div Yield %	3.67	6.5

KCLI makes 30% of its revenue from investments, therefore investment income is critical to be profitable. But in this low interest environment the company must sacrifice safety to get decent yield. The company has more than half of its assets in corporate bonds. Virtually all of its bonds are investment grade, but there is still a lot at the bottom tier of investment grade. When the downturn happened, there was a big fear that we would see a wave of corporate downgrades and defaults. Fortunately, the Fed pulled out the bazooka and said it was willing to buy up corporate debt to shore up the market.

In the report, the company still has $779 M of equity, even after factoring in Q1 losses. That may seem like plenty but the company's capital and surplus (equity) for statutory regulation purposes is only $260 M at 2019 year end. This $260 M amount is used by regulators determine if the company is solvent and can do more business. So a deep downturn in the bond market can be very scary for the company. But they dodged a bullet, maybe, as the bond market has been quite bullish recently.

KCLI is a really conservative old insurance company. The Bixby family has run it for four generations! Philip Bixby CEO has run the company for the last two decades. Because the company is so stable, past data can be very useful to understand the company and its management intentions.

In the last 15 years, their overall book value has gone from $692 M to $779 M. Over the same period, their shares outstanding have gone from 11.9 M to 9.6 M, as they have consistently tried to buy their shares back, mostly in the $40-$50 range. So the net result is that their book value per share has gone from $51 to $81 in 15 years. That's a paltry 3.13% return.

Along with equity growth, shareholders also get a steady dividend. Sadly, since the current CEO has taken over the company twenty years ago, they have never increased the dividend, although one year, they did distribute a special dividend of $2 per share.

The stock is right now at $29.40 after the recent market drop, but at this level it still hasn't recovered like the favoured US large caps. If the company could return to around $36, that is a 3% dividend. Add the dividend to the 3.13% equity growth and overall, shareholders can expect around a 6.13% return.

This isn't a great return, but I just live with KCLI as a steady source of income. If I have spare cash, I can put it to work at KCLI. Or if I want to get adventurous, I could borrow money to buy KCLI. With interest rates so low, I can pocket the spread between the dividend and the interest cost.

My second insurance holding is European Reliance (ATH:EUPIC). This company is similar to KCLI. It does life, health and auto insurance for the Greek market. EUPIC had a great 2019, the company earned € 17.5 M, and € 22.4 M pre-tax. Of the pre-tax profit, € 7.3 M was from underwriting, and all other was € 15.1 M. As expected however, Q1 2020 was bad news. The company's book value dropped by € 13 M. Again, it was better than I feared, because I saw that they have downside exposure to € 30 M of Greek mutual funds. The ratios in the table are as of Q1 2020, so they still aren't bad. If that is the worst of it, EUPIC is a good company selling for really cheap. And it is very generous with the dividends. I added to my position during this downturn.

That's the second update of my holdings. Next post I will update my cigarette stocks.